I encountered the same thing and contacted Help via Chat.  They informed me that all was working fine but somehow I had not met all of the conditions to receive the award.  I agree that this is disappointing .

We have used AARP recipes to create a special theme night dinner.  We go all out to  create a meal featuring a type of cuisine (i.e Ethiopian, Greek, Italian) or a theme ( 50’s, beach in winter, fine dining) .  This can be done much more economically...