Skip to main content
Contributor ⭐⭐⭐
Nov 13, 2026 2:46 AM UTC

A word to the wise on retiree health insurance.

Perhaps stating the obvious here, but unless you truly can’t afford better, PLEASE stay away from Medicare Advantage healthcare plans.  Sure, there may be one (maybe two) Advantage plans out there that do a good job for seniors, but the remaining thousand(s) are just plain rip offs!

Go with Traditional Medicare plus a supplement.  Sure, the Medicare Supplement Plans are going to get expensive 10-15 years down the road but you’ll still be alive to enjoy them (vs rolling the dice with an advantage insurance company telling you “you’re just too darned expensive for us to keep you alive”)!

11 replies

Contributor ⭐⭐⭐
Nov 19, 2026 4:54 AM UTC

Medicare Supplemental and Medicare Advantage plans vary by state.

What is nationwide,  is that currently, you can only change from Medicare Advantage to/from Medicare Supplemental or vice versa without underwriting once.

After that, you are subjected to underwriting if you want to change back to Original Medicare Supplental or Advantage again.

You CAN switch within the Supplemental or Advantage without underwriting during annual open enrollment or due to certain changes during the year.

In Ohio, Medicare Advantage is by FAR the way to go unless you have certain health conditions, such as an organ transplant, dialysis, certain (but not most) cancers.

With a Supplemental plan, I would pay Medicare B,D  $209.50 and at least $250-over $1k a month for a Supplemental plus a large deductible. OVER $460 to $1200 /mo just for Original Medicare plus a supplemental.

For Medicare Advantage, I have many plans that are only the $209.50 B/D assignment (and a few "give back" part of that).  They include some dental, vision, hearing, Silver Sneakers, OTC credit and more.

Prior authorizations are needed for some things,  but i and other senior friends and family have not had a problem with approvals.

For example:

My Uncle had both hips replaced last year and paid $770 total for everything, including physical therapy.  This year, he got hearing aides for under $400.  He is NOT on Medicaid, this is Medigold Advantage.  He pays $42.90/mo, Medigold Cashback "gives back" $160/mo. His ss check only $42.90 taken out not $202.90

Primary Dr visits are 0 copay, specialist $40.

Dental allows 2 cleaning, bitewing xrays, pays 50% on fillings or certain other dental (up to $1k)

$25/mo otc credit at CVS for catalog items (vitamins, toothpaste,socks,etc)

Going out of state (not for snowbirds) ? They actually have limited coverage to get you stable and back to Ohio (you have to notify them in advance etc, but it is something)

And more.  For $42.50/mo vs the $460-$1200/mo

We know people who are cancer survivors who have the same great experiences.

Please check out your STATE options.

 

Contributor ⭐⭐
Nov 19, 2026 5:06 AM UTC

None of my docs here in Nashville area accept the MA.  I have Part G Supplement (the highest level).  It's going up $22 more per month.  I pay no co-pays or my part of the officer visit.  I don't even see a bill.  My Part D Drug Plan went from $119/mo with UHC to $60/mo with Humana.  Same coverage.  So I guess it all depends on what one is willing to pay out of pocket.  For me it was the most cost effective way to go

Contributor ⭐
Nov 18, 2026 4:12 AM UTC

I work in healthcare and from my employer experience, these medicare advantage plans are a nightmare to work with, we have to fight to get an authorization for medically necessary procedures then we have to fight and appeal to get paid for the very same procedure that we fought to get approved in the first place. Yes as another person mentioned traditional medicare did roll out the WISER program and some procedures do require an authorization but those procedures require an authorization due to fraud and abuse of some of those procedures and it is to protect us, I say stay away from medicare advantage plans and stick with traditional medicare. 

Contributor ⭐⭐
Nov 18, 2026 5:13 AM UTC

The WISeR program has only been rolled out to a select few states.  I think like 6 states.  Not in any case I would never go with the MA plan.  

Conversationalist ⭐⭐⭐
Nov 17, 2026 11:18 PM UTC

Totally agree with you!  I have my traditional health insurance (actually one I’ve used for several years) that I know and the premiums have increased a bit but still more affordable that many others. I also know and review any changes annually. The deductible and maximum spending cap have remained the same for the past 5 years. Still a bargain!  I also like the fact that my health insurance also allows for Medicare reimbursement. I can manage my Health Spending account (HSA) by requesting the Medicare reimbursement if I see that the HSA is too large and my previous employer will not have to pay the required HSA contribution.  Monitoring the HSA also keeps more money in MY pocket than theirs since my insurance requires the use of the HSA before the annual spending cap kicks in that may delay the actual insurance from paying as much.

 

I see far too many issues on Medicare Advantage advertisements and commercials!  They do seem to make wild promises!  Many people don’t realize just what is paid for under traditional Medicare!  I even have family that refuse to read the Medicare benefit brochure that everyone on Medicare get annually! One family member told me her Doctor told her a tetanus shot wasn’t covered unless he when to the Drug Store!  The Doctor’s office was just too lazy to file or unwilling to accept the Medicare payment.  

 

STAY AWAY FROM MEDICARE ADVANTAGE UNLESS YOU HAVE NO OTHER OPTION!!!

 

 

Contributor ⭐⭐
Nov 17, 2026 11:57 PM UTC

The reason a lot of agents push the Advantage program is because their commission is far higher from the insurer.  I've you sign with avMA program you are locked in until the next open enrollment. B not so with Medigap Part G.

 

I also prefer a stand alone Part D drug plan even though the annual cap has increased from $2100 to $2400. I just don't like the AARP UHC plan as they almost doubled the premium.  So went with Humana

Contributor ⭐⭐
Nov 17, 2026 2:47 PM UTC

Please make sure you do your due diligence.  Medicare Advantage plans are not that great. I personally would never go with them.  Most of my doctors do not accept the MA plan and lots of practices are dropping them.  

Contributor ⭐⭐
Nov 16, 2026 4:30 AM UTC

People who recommend choosing a supplement plan over an advantage plan are either ignoring or are unaware of the WISER pilot program which began running in 6 states this past January. Original Medicare does currently use prior authorization for a limited number of procedures (its denial rate for these procedures is about 28%). Beginning in January, it expanded this preauthorization program for about a dozen other procedures, contracting this out to AI companies who are paid up to 25% of the cost savings the program generates. The AI companies involved in this can be traced to private equity. In these 6 states, in the first 3 months, two AI companies denied almost 6000 requests for care. In Washington state,  more requests were denied than approved. It's too complicated to trace who these companies are here but if you are interested check out the video from A More Perfect Union called "AI is being used to deny your health care". Meanwhile,  the current administration plans to expand the WISER program to more services including ambulances, MRIs and cancer, then bring AI into the whole of Medicare "from diagnostics to therapy". So a few years down the road that expensive supplement plan you have that you think is going to protect from denial of care, well, maybe not.

sktn77aAuthor
Contributor ⭐⭐⭐
Nov 16, 2026 12:44 PM UTC

Interesting.  Given the world as we know it, right now I’d rather have a “bird in the hand………...”   Having said that, if indeed Medicare goes this direction big time, I can still chose between the two and make the switch.  Anybody with an MA plan of course, can not (unless they can pass underwriting).

SummerOnTheWay1
Nov 13, 2026 2:56 AM UTC

​@sktn77a , interesting you posted this as I just signed up for one of Aetna's Medicare Advantage plans for 2027. I am totally looking forward to using it.

Question & no pressure to respond, I will understand.

Are you speaking from a personal experience with a Medicare Advantage Plan?

sktn77aAuthor
Contributor ⭐⭐⭐
Nov 13, 2026 3:15 AM UTC

“Are you speaking from a personal experience with a Medicare Advantage Plan?”

Fortunately not!   But you just have to read all the posts on this and other fora about people whose care has been denied by the MA insurance company bean counters. 

To be fair, you’ll also see posts about the increasing costs of Medicare Supplement plans but not about care being denied.