AARP Opposes Attempts to Remove the ACA's Law Age Rating Limits and Pre-Existing Conditions Protections. Learn More!

Reply
Conversationalist

Re: Age Discrimination in Job Search and the Workplace

138 Views
Message 1 of 113

uh.... so you think AARP taking seniors money is a good business model? OK

Report Inappropriate Content
Conversationalist

Re: Age Discrimination in Job Search and the Workplace

140 Views
Message 2 of 113

Protest only works if the news decides to cover the story. Guess what. The news doesn't want to cover a story about age discrimination. So go ahead an protest all you want. No one will hear you.... This country is screwed. We have seen the best of America in ourt times. I have my doubts if it even makes another 10 years..

Report Inappropriate Content
Conversationalist

Re: Age Discrimination in Job Search and the Workplace

170 Views
Message 3 of 113

Gail:

 

I already knew and understood your repetition of information about "it has to go to the courts" and "precedent" and all that.  Most of it is basic Civics 101. Please don't patronize me and others on this board. Most of us are well educated and already understand how courts work. Of course I agree with your explanatory statements of fact about how the U.S. legal system works. 

 

What I disagree with is the assertion that "Protest doesn't work."  Immediately, you're correct: It doesn't usually work if the goal is immediate change.  What protest does accomplish is giving an issue publicity and traction so that (hopefully) enough people (especially those with the power to do something) urge legislators to change things or to bring lawsuits themselves.

 

Protest lights a fire under people to get them to care enough about something so they can DO something about the problem.  But if you want instant gratification, you're correct: Protest doesn't typically do that.  Still, that's no reason for anyone to sit at home on their **bleep** and gripe without doing anything. 

 

 

Report Inappropriate Content
Frequent Social Butterfly

Re: Age Discrimination in Job Search and the Workplace

208 Views
Message 4 of 113

@perryj165369, They don't WANT money they need money to stay in business just like you need money to live. I don't like trivializing anyone/thing trying to survive.  That is an important truth in life.

Report Inappropriate Content
Frequent Social Butterfly

Re: Age Discrimination in Job Search and the Workplace

211 Views
Message 5 of 113

@GailL1, I can dissagree.  MLK got it right.  The 60s protests were so effective because they were non violent.  TV had cops beating the protesters that were just stating a point.  That created huge sympathy for the cause.  Most of the US abhore violance.  Violent protests generate at least as much backlash as support.  Violance is a sign of crazy and unhinged. The crazy just don't get that because they are crazy!

Report Inappropriate Content
Valued Social Butterfly

Re: Age Discrimination in Job Search and the Workplace

289 Views
Message 6 of 113

@JulieK260428 wrote:

>Rights enthusiast who march, protest, rant and rave, seek media attention to matters by their voice and >actions, etc. only give one side of the issue - the other side does their own of the same sometimes.  >They don't actually fix anything, they just get possible attention.  Any actual fix is done in the Courts.

 

Disagree.  Protest is exactly how issues get onto the public's radar.  Just look at the #meToo movement and the Florida school shooting efforts.  Have they solved the problem completely? No, but that's too much to expect of them.  Instead they get the causes out there for discussion everywhere and the courts then MUST listen.  Witness the CA judge recently voted out of office for going easy on sentencing of a college kid found guilty of rape.   The school shooter protests have gotten some incremental change in Florida where pretty quickly the state raised the age to buy a gun to 21.

 

Try telling the '60s civil rights protesters that protest doesn't "actually fix anything."  It's one of the few things, if done right, that DOES change things. 

 

Besides, we have the right to protest.  It's the way people all over the world make their voices heard.  If it "didn't work" people would have stopped protesting long ago.

 

 


NEW Laws come from a governing body - Congress at the Federal level, so, yes protest, rant and raves, media attention might direct them to work on a new law but that too has to go through a process and then it could still be challenged in a Court of law by somebody bringing a court action.

 

If a problem involves a law change or modification, somebody still has to take it to Court for the law to be scrutinized.  It may have to go all the way up to the SCOTUS as our Court system hierarchy works.  A case has to set a precedent* for the laws interpretation and all the justified appeals have to take place.

 

Precedent. In common law legal systems, a precedent, or authority, is a principle or rule established in a previous legal case that is either binding on or persuasive for a court or other legal body to rule along these lines for cases going forward.

 

Like I said, protest, media attention, rant and raves on either side, or both,  of an issue can bring and keep focus on an issue but if it involves a Law, then their has to be action via a case in the Court system.

 

Just like one of the issues we are talking about here - the law, the ADEA, has been and is being challenged by not employees but applicants for employment and what might be the standard for a potential employers to set as a maximum line of experience.

 

Since there most times two sides to every story or two participant classificatns in each challenge, each with a point of view, there has to be a ruling by the Courts as to what is fair and just when a challenge to a law is made.  It is not always just a black and white or right or wrong issue - lots of grey area.

 

How else could it be done when challenging a law or even part of a law that is already on the books?

Report Inappropriate Content
Highlighted
Conversationalist

Re: Age Discrimination in Job Search and the Workplace

385 Views
Message 7 of 113

>Rights enthusiast who march, protest, rant and rave, seek media attention to matters by their voice and >actions, etc. only give one side of the issue - the other side does their own of the same sometimes.  >They don't actually fix anything, they just get possible attention.  Any actual fix is done in the Courts.

 

Disagree.  Protest is exactly how issues get onto the public's radar.  Just look at the #meToo movement and the Florida school shooting efforts.  Have they solved the problem completely? No, but that's too much to expect of them.  Instead they get the causes out there for discussion everywhere and the courts then MUST listen.  Witness the CA judge recently voted out of office for going easy on sentencing of a college kid found guilty of rape.   The school shooter protests have gotten some incremental change in Florida where pretty quickly the state raised the age to buy a gun to 21.

 

Try telling the '60s civil rights protesters that protest doesn't "actually fix anything."  It's one of the few things, if done right, that DOES change things. 

 

Besides, we have the right to protest.  It's the way people all over the world make their voices heard.  If it "didn't work" people would have stopped protesting long ago.

 

 

Report Inappropriate Content
Valued Social Butterfly

Re: Age Discrimination in Job Search and the Workplace

397 Views
Message 8 of 113

@perryj165369 wrote:

I agree... all they want is money to pay their execs... I'm really disappointed in AARP... I have the perfect case for discrimination and they haven't even reached out to me... It's all about the money...


I don't think they reach out to you - much like any other court case, it is up to the person to find legal counsel and tell their story, presenting proof of the facts,

to see if there is grounds for a complaint.

 

Have you tried reaching out to them?

AARP Foundation - Legal Advocacy - Litigation - Our Work

 

Remeber . . . . If it is to be, it is up to me.

 

 

Report Inappropriate Content
Conversationalist

Re: Age Discrimination in Job Search and the Workplace

455 Views
Message 9 of 113

AARP does nothing except ask for donations...

Report Inappropriate Content
Conversationalist

Re: Age Discrimination in Job Search and the Workplace

461 Views
Message 10 of 113

I agree... all they want is money to pay their execs... I'm really disappointed in AARP... I have the perfect case for discrimination and they haven't even reached out to me... It's all about the money...

Report Inappropriate Content