United Healthcare- Should not be sponsored by AARP

I went to the Medicare site and looked for a company that might have a plan to replace my pathetic plan by Emblem. My wife and I looked at which doctors were part of the United Healthcare AARP plan. When we started, my primary care provider was listed so I went ahead and applied. I got a confirmation letter. Since my wife is being treated for lymphoma and has more doctors than I do, we looked up all of the doctors treating her and NOT one was listed as participating. We looked up five and none were listed.


What really upsets me is the wait for a representative but more importantly that they transferred me three times and I wound up in sales because the other representatives would not help me as they probably wanted to transfer me to sales.The sales person told me that she would look on the list to see if there was a mistake and I had "misread" the doctors list. I am a retired teacher - an English teacher- and to imply that I could not follow the list was insulting. The representative insisted on looking it up and she claimed that one of my wife's doctors was listed. I questioned this and she looked again and saw that the doctor took certain United plans but NOT plans involving Medicare Advantage. What bothered me the most is that like the lists at my "beloved" Emblem, the lists were very wrong about things. I even saw on a list that was for pharmacies that are participating, a listing of a pharmacy in my neighborhood that had been closed for THREE years.


I asked the sales representative why the lists are so incorrect and outdated. She told me that entries are changed or taken out if the doctors or pharmacies update them and notify United. REALLY? And you have the customers make his decision about a plan based on a list that is inaccurate. . Wow! If I owned that pharmacy, the very first thing I would do if I were closing was to call United. It would be my ultimate responsibility. Seriously? Shouldn't they revise their lists (United and Emblem) by hiring help to check the lists, to update them. BAD BUSINESS!!!! So sad, so inept, so dumb!!!

Periodic Contributor

I completely agree.  I'm appalled that AARP has associated itself with United Healthcare and my experience with the latter has left a bad taste in my mouth for several reasons.  One is that their list of 8 opticians in my zip code turns out to have only 2 that are actually taking the United Healthcare insurance, and their prices AFTER insurance are more than an out-of-network optician nearby.  WAY more -- by a couple hundred dollars.  One on the list is not only closed, but the woman who ran it died in 2010!


I sincerely agree with you about AARP UNITEDHEALTH. MY MEDICARE SUPPLEMENTAL HEALTH INSURANCE POLICY PREMIUM INCREASED BY 200% PERCENT?? WHY BECAUSE THEY STARTED USING A ORGANIZATION THAT SCORES A INDIVIDUALS BASED ON YOUR MEDICAL HISTORY, PERSONAL DEMOGRAPHICALLY INFORMATION , DIAGNOSIS,  MEDICATION prescribed, medical tests taken, any special medical equipment used and the number and frequency of Doctor office visits. They can't deny you  because of a preexisting medical conditions, but you pay an ridiculous premium amount for coverage that only pays 20% of medical bill costs. 




I am a bit confused about your post.


Were you covered by a UHC Medigap plan and wanted to change to a different letter plan with the same carrier? If so, underwriting may be required. The UHC underwriting guide may call for a Level 2 rate for high risk if you no longer qualify for a standard rate.


You are not REQUIRED to accept the higher rate. You can keep your existing plan.


Did you relocate to a different address? If keeping the same plan your rate may be adjusted to reflect the new cost area, but underwriting is usually not required.


If this is an underwritten plan you can be denied coverage in most states.


It seems obvious your agent was neglectful in explaining the process.

Bark less. Wag more.

I turn 65 last January in 2020 and enrolled into AARP United Healthcare supplement plan G with automatic payment for $117 a month. My April $117 premium was already paid by EFT. I just noticed in May, my supplement premium will be increased to $205. I did not receive any notice from United Healthcare.


I am most grateful to you that you can share some of the information:


1.) In United Health Care, are there Level 3, Level 4 and the premium will continue increasing as time goes by?


2) General speaking, if a person developed an illness on 65 or beyond, it will be difficult for him to switch to other insurance companies because of pre-exist condition?


Thank you very much. Have a nice evening


Social Butterfly



I’d recommend you just give UHC a call and ask why your premium went from $117 a month to $205 a month. I’ve always found them to be very helpful on the phone when I have questions.

In my state most supplement/medigap plans offer what I call a “teaser” premium rate for people new to Medicare.
For instance, when I enrolled in a UHC letter plan I was given a 30% discount on the premium. Then every year for the next 10 years my premium gradually increased 3% each year until my premium was no longer discounted. But also, the premium will increase each year because costs for medical services go up each year. So, you have two increases in your premium for 10 years through UHC.

The several Insurance companies I considered purchasing a supplement plan from (back in the day) all had these special low incentive rates. Some recovered in 2, 4, 5 years but they all eventually took your discount away.

They all do it I didn’t see anything wrong with it. At least I received a little bit of a discount. It’s all documented in the papers you signed with the company.

Honored Social Butterfly


There are several ways that premiums on Medigap plans can be set.  These links describe them as well as when you can sign up for initial enrollment and (generally) when you can change, IF you can change sometimes and at what consequence. - What's Medigap - When can I buy Medigap? - Cost & Pricing of Medigap Plans 

Many of the sign up/change rules/manner of increases for Medigap plans are based on state law - like when and if you can change plans and at what consequence. 

So knowing what state you are in or where you bought the Plan G policy might help knowing what is going on.  That's a large increase - were you given some sort of a discount for the 1st year?  Have you talked to your agent or the insurer?

Your Medigap plan that you initially pick stays in effect continuously forever UNLESS you stop making payments. 


As an example for the State of NY - UHC AARP branded Supplemental Plans issued this REQUEST for an increase in January 2021, effective in June 2021 to the State of NY Insurance Dept.  UnitedHealthcare Insurance Company of New York AARP® Medicare Supplement Insurance Plans Rate Increa... 


per the link - this rate increase request is for:

Premium rate changes have been requested because the costs of providing benefits are changing:

  • Costs for medical services continue to increase
  • Medicare deductibles that are covered under these plans are expected to be higher
  • Members are using more costly state-of-the-art medical equipment and services
  • Together with the above factors, the use of medical services by members continues to change and may result in higher, lower or the same overall costs of providing benefits
It's Always Something . . . . Roseanna Roseannadanna
Honored Social Butterfly


That is NOT normally the way a Medicare Supplemental (MEDIGAP) plan works or determines the amount of your premium.  IF you changed plans, especially to another insurer, after your initial enrollment period and your state does not specifically have rules that cover your ability to change plans after your initial enrollment period, then YES, the new insurer CAN use underwriting for the new policy which can result in higher premiums OR EVEN A DENIAL OF COVERAGE.


However, if you have been with this Medigap plan for a long time, then something else is going on - (see the Medicare link below on the Cost & Pricing of Medigap plans. - What's Medigap - When can I buy Medigap? - Cost & Pricing of Medigap Plans 


It's Always Something . . . . Roseanna Roseannadanna
0 Kudos
Periodic Contributor

This is Sad, these things should have a system or atleast they should update these lists.


We eventually went with Blue Cross/Blue Shield. They are rated poorly but since we have been with Emblem/Hip for forty years, we have given them a pessimistic try. We just could not bear to give Emblem another dime because in the last three or four years customer service has been bad to vile. 


These lists I am complaining about are not up to date on the Medicare site...So you can use the company's list or the Medicare site and you will not see a list that is very faulty - very incorrect. If you call customer service - guess what the customer service person will look up the list you saw and use it, insisting it is up-to-date. Even if you look up a doctor and he/she is on the list, you had better call the doctor to verify current status. on the other hand, if your doctor is not on the list, it is possible he should not be on the list since everything is questionable. If you have a primary care doctor and five specialists, you have got some important phone calls to make before buying a different plan with a different company. Good luck and be persistent!


As for Aarp, I admire this organization a lot and I understand that they get royalties from United but with the organization's power, wouldn't you think that they might "request" that United get its act together! ?

Regular Contributor

This is not unique to UHC in any way. What you experienced is the issue with ALL Medicare Advantage plans. Unlike Medigap, Medicare Advantage plans can change at any time of the year. Your provider can leave the plan whenever they want, leaving you with a plan that your primary care physicians no longer accept and you cannot change plans until the next Open Enrollment Period. It's very possible the provider recently left the plan and that's why they are no longer on the carrier provider list. Again, not specific to AARP or UHC. This is with all managed care plans. Unfortunately, you could very well have the same issue with BCBS. If you want to avoid this, try enrolling in a Medigap plan instead. However, if your health is poor, you may be denied coverage if you're outside your Medigap Open Enrollment Period. But it does not hurt to try. 


Thank you so much @ElliotS204698  for having the guts to step up and report all of the rocks you are encountering along this road. I can't imagine what it must be like for your wife & you; to have to deal with the disease itself. But, to have to go up against the company you thought was your protection, is too much. I pray that things get better for you and your wife especially. I hope that the organization can use this as a learning tool, for advance repairs in different areas of AARP. While much of America is shut down sort of, corporate America needs to take this opportunity to fine tune all of their systems that interact with the public; from the outside... in! We the people and our needs are real! I was reading your article and saw people were scared or something to respond & I thought of the old Bobby Womack hit, Nobody Wants You When You're Down & Out. Hang in there, I'm proud of you. No matter what God will see you through!

Honored Social Butterfly

United Healthcare isn't sponsored by AARP -

For use of their (branded) name, AARP receives royalties from UHC - thus UHC AARP Medicare plans are a revenue source for AARP.

Read the Disclosure:

AARP® Medicare Advantage from UnitedHealthcare 


AARP commercial member benefits are provided by third parties, not by AARP or its affiliates. Providers pay a royalty fee to AARP for the use of its intellectual property. These fees are used for the general purposes of AARP. Some provider offers are subject to change and may have restrictions.

State Availability

Not available in Alaska, Delaware, Maryland, Michigan, Mississippi, Montana, Wyoming, or the U.S. territories.


Since most MA plans work with (constantly changing) networks of doctors and other health professionals and those networks are based on contractual agreements, either party can change them.


Your best source of MA health insurance coverage with a specific doctor is to check with their own insurance representative in the doc's office - also find out how they could be listed on the specific plan - group or individual.  They might also be able to tell you other MA groups for which the medical provider or other health provider is affiliated. 


If specific providers were the end goal, perhaps traditional Medicare would have been a better choice if the providers take Medicare at all - course, switching now may leave you financially vulnerable if there are high healthcare cost or pre-existing conditions because a Medigap policy might be denied, or very expensive and contain some exclusions for a period due to health.


You have until Monday (December 7) to switch MA plans during open enrollment. 


As far as their ability to keep their list of providers updated - says this and describes some of the different types of coverage available under MA plans - HMO, PPO, PFFS, SNP - familiarize yourself for your benefit: - Medicare Advantage Plans 

Medicare Advantage Plans are another way to get your Medicare Part A and Part B coverage. Medicare Advantage Plans, sometimes called “Part C” or “MA Plans,” are offered by Medicare-approved private companies that must follow rules set by Medicare. Most Medicare Advantage Plans include drug coverage (Part D). In many cases, you’ll need to use health care providers who participate in the plan’s network and service area for the lowest costs. These plans set a limit on what you’ll have to pay out-of-pocket each year for covered services, to help protect you from unexpected costs. Some plans offer out-of-network coverage, but sometimes at a higher cost.


Just like any other insurance - the more options, the more inclusive, the higher the (premium) cost.


It's Always Something . . . . Roseanna Roseannadanna

I am not having some of the problems with Unite Healthcare that others are - they are simply not paying my providers - after six months and multiple phone calls by me and my provider.  They told me when I signed up that my providers were covered and confirm that when I call them, but they are not paying and I've had to pay in full the charges from my providers because they can't afford to wait any longer for payment.  AARP should not be advertising, promoting, endorsing, etc, this company.  It was on te strength of their recommendation that we went with  them, and we now have no fait in AARP's recommendations, suggestions, etc.

Honored Social Butterfly


Something sounds wrong here but where the problem might be is anybody's guess.  Providers do come and go in specific networks - it is up to them.

So here is one more place to check -

Get out your AARP - UHC MA plan insurance card and note the exact name of the plan - then call your provider's office and talk to the person that submits the claims cause it sure sounds like the provider is NOT in the SPECIFIC plan that you currently have. 

Are you even getting a notice from your insurance plan that they are paying or not paying for the services that you have used?  They should be giving you this notice when the claim is processed and if not paid, giving you a reason as to why not.

AARP UHC Medicare Advantage have several plan types and it is up to the provider to be enrolled in specific type plans.  I assume that you know what type of coverage you have - The name of the plan should be plainly stated on your insurance card and the provider has to be in THAT specific plan.

Here is a list of the types. 

Screenshot_2021-02-07 Compare Medicare Advantage Plans AARP Medicare Plans.png




It's Always Something . . . . Roseanna Roseannadanna
0 Kudos
Info Seeker

Our dentist left UHC in August of 2022 due to such poor payment, if any. I am considering leaving UHC because of their unpredictable coverage. The problem is, according to our dental office, it isn't just UHC. I was told it was a problem with all Medicare Advantage programs. This is so frustrating. I just feel trapped into having to accept substandard insurance policies. It's hard enough getting old without this kind of stress.

Periodic Contributor

Hi Victoria --- After I made my post to this discussion on 10-18-2021, we left UHC and went with another company and were really pleasantly surprised to find that they are paying a good proportion of our dental bills!  So there ARE some Medicare Advantage programs that cover dentists.  

Info Seeker

Oops sorry Liz, I don't know where Nicole came from.

Info Seeker

That's good to know, Nicole. Would you be willing to tell me who you went with? It would be nice to know since you are having good results with them. Thanks so much, Victoria

Trusted Social Butterfly

 1 comment (11/29/22) @lizcooksey is there a list we can access online? Thanks, Nicole 

0 Kudos
Periodic Contributor

I made my choice a year ago from an online list, but didn't explicitly choose this company for the dental coverage.  Finding out they do cover it was a surprise bonus.  I was choosing based on how quickly I could get to a real person who was helpful.  It's Regence MedAdv +Rx Primary PPO.  I didn't mention it to begin with for fear of people's thinking I was being compensated by them for posting.  I'm not at all affiliated with them except as a satisfied customer.  We're staying with them this year. 

Showing results for 
Show  only  | Search instead for 
Did you mean: 
Need to Know

"I downloaded AARP Perks to assist in staying connected and never missing out on a discount!" -LeeshaD341679

AARP Perks

More From AARP