I agree that auctions were exciting. Auction would be a great way to use points. However, if auctions were to return, I would hope that they would not come back with point tiers.
The old program, Rewards for Good, had several point tiers. The tiers worked so that a gift card for say $10 would โcostโ a person with a lot of points accumulated more than a person with fewer points accumulated. The difference was astounding. The person with a lots of points would never seen the auctions going on in the lower tiers. One could only see the difference by looking at the list of auction winners.
The group running the AARP Rewards for Good, explained that the tiers allowed those with fewer points to win an auction. That would be accurate; but I saw it that to win auction, I โpaidโ a lot of points for the same dollar amount gift card that someone in a lower tier โpaid.โ The program penalized a person who saved points.