Ace Icon
The ACE badge is awarded to Online Community members who have been recognized by peers for their high value contributions.

Learn More

The Online Community ACE program enables you to be recognized by your peers for consistent, high value contributions to the Community.

Are you ready to become an ACE? Here's how:

  • Upload Your Profile Picture
  • Fill Out the "Tell us about yourself" Section
  • Share Your "Areas of knowledge"
  • Receive 25 Kudos (excluding Politics, Current Events forum) during rolling six month period
  • Be In Good Standing Without Community Violations For At Least 30 Days

All Activity

Thanks everyone for joining in on this discussion.  You all made excellent points and helped me decide on our best approach.  In the end I think that @Tonster521 has a complete analysis of the problem and the solution.  I was nearly at the same point...
MichaelD180397 02-06-2021 01:55 PM
0
Replies
0
Kudos
2075
Views
@Tonster521 I think you've nailed it.  Taxes and interest payments had me going back and forth to the spreadsheet formulas a few times but I had neglected both the amortization and the lost gains from the 401k. FWIW the HELOC is adjustable, but at pr...
MichaelD180397 02-06-2021 01:50 PM
0
Replies
0
Kudos
2082
Views
@GailL1  - Well done.  I had completely forgotten about the medicare income thresholds.  A $100,000 withdrawal from the 401lk, would still have us below the $176,000 threshold where the increase kicks in from $148.50 to $207.90.  Alas, we've already ...
MichaelD180397 02-04-2021 12:51 PM
0
Replies
0
Kudos
1755
Views
Excellent points @fffred . I'm afraid there is no escaping the 22% trap but I'm building my spreadsheet now trying to determine the real difference in cost between the taxes paid vs the interest on the loan. Your suggestion to parcel out the distribu...
MichaelD180397 02-04-2021 12:37 PM
1
Reply
0
Kudos
1764
Views
Hi Gail -  Thanks for that. I think you've summed up our thoughts on the HELOC vs 401K distribution and the taxes that go along with that.  I should have mentioned that we do still owe some on the mortgage, about 25% of the current value.  I'm still ...
MichaelD180397 02-03-2021 06:50 PM
1
Reply
1
Kudo
2242
Views
Thanks everyone for joining in on this discussion.  You all made excellent points and helped me decide on our best approach.  In the end I think that @Tonster521 has a complete analysis of the problem and the solution.  I was nearly at the same point...
MichaelD180397 02-06-2021 01:55 PM
0
Replies
0
Kudos
2075
Views
@Tonster521 I think you've nailed it.  Taxes and interest payments had me going back and forth to the spreadsheet formulas a few times but I had neglected both the amortization and the lost gains from the 401k. FWIW the HELOC is adjustable, but at pr...
MichaelD180397 02-06-2021 01:50 PM
0
Replies
0
Kudos
2082
Views
@GailL1  - Well done.  I had completely forgotten about the medicare income thresholds.  A $100,000 withdrawal from the 401lk, would still have us below the $176,000 threshold where the increase kicks in from $148.50 to $207.90.  Alas, we've already ...
MichaelD180397 02-04-2021 12:51 PM
0
Replies
0
Kudos
1755
Views
Excellent points @fffred . I'm afraid there is no escaping the 22% trap but I'm building my spreadsheet now trying to determine the real difference in cost between the taxes paid vs the interest on the loan. Your suggestion to parcel out the distribu...
MichaelD180397 02-04-2021 12:37 PM
1
Reply
0
Kudos
1764
Views
Hi Gail -  Thanks for that. I think you've summed up our thoughts on the HELOC vs 401K distribution and the taxes that go along with that.  I should have mentioned that we do still owe some on the mortgage, about 25% of the current value.  I'm still ...
MichaelD180397 02-03-2021 06:50 PM
1
Reply
1
Kudo
2242
Views
Thanks everyone for joining in on this discussion.  You all made excellent points and helped me decide on our best approach.  In the end I think that @Tonster521 has a complete analysis of the problem and the solution.  I was nearly at the same point...
MichaelD180397 02-06-2021 01:55 PM
0
Replies
0
Kudos
2075
Views
@Tonster521 I think you've nailed it.  Taxes and interest payments had me going back and forth to the spreadsheet formulas a few times but I had neglected both the amortization and the lost gains from the 401k. FWIW the HELOC is adjustable, but at pr...
MichaelD180397 02-06-2021 01:50 PM
0
Replies
0
Kudos
2082
Views
@GailL1  - Well done.  I had completely forgotten about the medicare income thresholds.  A $100,000 withdrawal from the 401lk, would still have us below the $176,000 threshold where the increase kicks in from $148.50 to $207.90.  Alas, we've already ...
MichaelD180397 02-04-2021 12:51 PM
0
Replies
0
Kudos
1755
Views
Excellent points @fffred . I'm afraid there is no escaping the 22% trap but I'm building my spreadsheet now trying to determine the real difference in cost between the taxes paid vs the interest on the loan. Your suggestion to parcel out the distribu...
MichaelD180397 02-04-2021 12:37 PM
1
Reply
0
Kudos
1764
Views
Hi Gail -  Thanks for that. I think you've summed up our thoughts on the HELOC vs 401K distribution and the taxes that go along with that.  I should have mentioned that we do still owe some on the mortgage, about 25% of the current value.  I'm still ...
MichaelD180397 02-03-2021 06:50 PM
1
Reply
1
Kudo
2242
Views
Public Statistics
Date Registered ‎02-03-2021 03:55 PM
Last Visited ‎02-06-2021 11:42 PM
Total Messages Posted 7
Total Kudos Received 2
cancel
Showing results for 
Show  only  | Search instead for 
Did you mean: 
Users