It's definitely odd. At no point during the quote process did they ask for my AARP number, just my birthday. And, based on that, they decided there's no way I could be an AARP member.

Firstly, hello. This is my first post here.I was thrilled to learn I can save a good chunk of change as an AARP member by switching my car insurance to The Hartford. So, I followed the link here on the AARP site that sent me to the Hartford to take a...