@mjt1959 wrote:
I was looking to purchase a magazine subscription through the rewards program which seemed like a good deal.
It pays to check before you buy!
I have said this before and I will say it again.
The rewards program is mostly a sham. You have found it out on your own, @mjt1959, but I have many other examples.
Coupons for Quiznos that weren't accepted by the restaurant designated on the coupon because they said they never joined the reward program.
Coupons for local restaurants that offered, just as in your case, better coupons or deals if you went directly through them.
But my best story is about a coupon in the AARP Rewards Program for a free greens fee on a golf course. It FIRST APPEARED on the rewards program ONE YEAR AFTER the course had been closed by the government, fenced and padlocked, weeds had replaced grass. The owners had committed some type of financial crime and the course was seized. The land was eventually sold for the building of apartments. The Entertainment Book and AARP were responsible for the Rewards Program at the time, I don't know if they still are.... although, based on your experience, it seems like they are still up to their inferior "rewards".
As a side note, always negotiate subscriptions.... I get 3 years of Time for $30, that's about 18 cents an issue, I get Smithsonian for a dollar an issue, I even got AARP membership for $31 for FIVE YEARS or just over $6 a year, lower than you will ever see AARP publicly advertise it.