Our Ignorance of Socialism Is Dangerous

Reply
Valued Social Butterfly
0
Kudos
158
Views

Re: Our Ignorance of Socialism Is Dangerous

158 Views
Message 31 of 141

 


@ChasKy53 wrote:

@rk9152 wrote:

@Richva wrote:

@rk9152 wrote:

The point of the topic was to discuss it not to post, "Conservatives think this and Conservatives think that".

The danger comes from not being aware of where "Socialism light" can lead.


oint. And I posted that it is thought of here as everywhere from Marx's theory in toto on one end to public libraries on the other.
The danger is adding little by little of 

What the hell does "Socialism ligh" mean?  I suspect you cannot define Socialism or socialism light (or heavy or wide or soft or hard.....). If you cannot define the term, how can you educate us of its dangers?  

I remember an old Robert Heinlien book where they sent people off to a wilderness with the warning "Beware the Stobor".  After that, every new danger the individuals and groups encountered were deemed to be THE STOBOR.  Looks like you are making the same kind of warning.  "Beware the msilaicos!!!!"


If you read Marx you will understand full blown Socialism as a step towards Communism. The basic difference being that under Socialism everybody has the same, under Communism "we the people" represented by the government owns everything. As to Socialism light, you'll have to ask those who think that public libraries define Socialism.

 

The danger is taking those small steps away from individual freedom towards "we the people" collectivism and getting to the point of dependency and unable to come back.

 

What that has to do with "msilaicos" is a mystery


Actually your posting is a mystery. What is Socialism rk?  What countries are actually Socialist?


Have you not been reading my posts?

Report Inappropriate Content
0
Kudos
158
Views
Valued Social Butterfly
0
Kudos
162
Views

Re: Our Ignorance of Socialism Is Dangerous

162 Views
Message 32 of 141

@ChasKy53 wrote:

@rk9152 wrote:

@Richva wrote:

@rk9152 wrote:

@Richva wrote:

The topic?  I guess our ignorance of Socialism is dangerous since: 
  • Conservatives can not define the term
  • Conservatives believe that more efficient, cost effective, and more effective ways of delivering services as demonstrated by real world experiences must be "Socialist" for reasons they cannot articulate. 
  • Conservatives believe every liberal is a socialist. This is a bit like claiming every liberal is a member of Antifa (of course, we all WANT to be)
  • Conservatives continue to distribute this misinformation. 

Any possibility that we could honestly look at the reality that due to various degrees and definitions PEOPLE do not understand the meaning and potential dangers of Socialism?

 

There is no need to mind read and claim to know what others are thinking in an honest discussion. In that instance a PERSON states what they think.

 

I congratulate jim on trying to get an interesting discussion going. But it has become obvious that some only get defensive when the topic comes up. I don't understand why - the antithesis is Free Market Capitalism and I gladly state and defend my approval of it.


This HAS been an interesting discussion. Do you realize that NOT ONCE was anyone provided  a definition of Socialism?  Well, I did but I took it from the dictionary.  The folks on the right had no idea what they meant by the term and the folks on the left were more interested in whether a set of programs were more or less effective than what was currently in place.  

 

If you can't define what you mean, how can you pretend the ignorance of others is dangerous? 


The meaning of the word was jim's point. And I posted that it is thought of here as everywhere from Marx's theory in toto on one end to public libraries on the other.

 

The point of the topic was to discuss it not to post, "Conservatives think this and Conservatives think that".

 

The danger comes from not being aware of where "Socialism light" can lead.


So then ....... explain what "Socialism light" is and what it can lead to. Since you cannot rationally offer such an explanation without knowing what Socialism is, could you give your definition of it?


So then....have you not been reading my posts?

Report Inappropriate Content
0
Kudos
162
Views
Valued Social Butterfly
0
Kudos
151
Views

Re: Our Ignorance of Socialism Is Dangerous

151 Views
Message 33 of 141

@ChasKy53 wrote:

@rk9152 wrote:

@Richva wrote:

The topic?  I guess our ignorance of Socialism is dangerous since: 
  • Conservatives can not define the term
  • Conservatives believe that more efficient, cost effective, and more effective ways of delivering services as demonstrated by real world experiences must be "Socialist" for reasons they cannot articulate. 
  • Conservatives believe every liberal is a socialist. This is a bit like claiming every liberal is a member of Antifa (of course, we all WANT to be)
  • Conservatives continue to distribute this misinformation. 

Any possibility that we could honestly look at the reality that due to various degrees and definitions PEOPLE do not understand the meaning and potential dangers of Socialism?

 

There is no need to mind read and claim to know what others are thinking in an honest discussion. In that instance a PERSON states what they think.

 

I congratulate jim on trying to get an interesting discussion going. But it has become obvious that some only get defensive when the topic comes up. I don't understand why - the antithesis is Free Market Capitalism and I gladly state and defend my approval of it.


Speaking of interesting, honest, and adult discussion:

 

Since you accuse so many of either being a Socialist, or supporting Socialism, what do you think Socialism is?


Have you not been reading my posts?

Report Inappropriate Content
0
Kudos
151
Views
Valued Social Butterfly
0
Kudos
157
Views

Re: Our Ignorance of Socialism Is Dangerous

157 Views
Message 34 of 141

@ChasKy53 wrote:

@rk9152 wrote:


 

 

BTW - we do have posters that praise nations practicing a form of Socialism - you for one, as I recall.

 


So what countries practice true Socialism?


None in the "workers" paradise" sense envisioned by Marx demonstrating the naivety of his thinking. The USSR was a great example of the danger of thinking it is possible.

Report Inappropriate Content
0
Kudos
157
Views
Valued Social Butterfly
0
Kudos
157
Views

Re: Our Ignorance of Socialism Is Dangerous

157 Views
Message 35 of 141

@ChasKy53 wrote:

@rk9152 wrote:

@williamb39198 wrote:

As usual, more smokescreen blather from the right to cover up the obscene policies and appointees by the trump administration. And denial of the welfare program for the wealthy... by repubs. 

Interesting that JimC did not name the topic: “Our ignorance of authoritarianism

is dangerous”.

That seems like a more applicable topic as to what is happening in our Country and the World. 

And NH, Scout knows what he’s talking about!

Never Forget


It is entirely possible for intelligent people to discuss some subjects with feeling the need to throw in trump (with a small "t").

 

It is true, jim did not use authoritarian in the title. There is no reason such a topic could not be started.

 

Do you have any thoughts on this topic?

 


You mention  'intelligent people to discuss some subjects" without spelling trump with a small 't' ............... yet you spell Jim's name with a "small 't'".  Are you denigrating Jimc?

 

Got anything on the topic?


Sure, I've posted plenty.

Report Inappropriate Content
0
Kudos
157
Views
Valued Social Butterfly
1
Kudos
153
Views

Re: Our Ignorance of Socialism Is Dangerous

153 Views
Message 36 of 141

@rk9152 wrote:

@Richva wrote:

@rk9152 wrote:

The point of the topic was to discuss it not to post, "Conservatives think this and Conservatives think that".

The danger comes from not being aware of where "Socialism light" can lead.


oint. And I posted that it is thought of here as everywhere from Marx's theory in toto on one end to public libraries on the other.
The danger is adding little by little of 

What the hell does "Socialism ligh" mean?  I suspect you cannot define Socialism or socialism light (or heavy or wide or soft or hard.....). If you cannot define the term, how can you educate us of its dangers?  

I remember an old Robert Heinlien book where they sent people off to a wilderness with the warning "Beware the Stobor".  After that, every new danger the individuals and groups encountered were deemed to be THE STOBOR.  Looks like you are making the same kind of warning.  "Beware the msilaicos!!!!"


If you read Marx you will understand full blown Socialism as a step towards Communism. The basic difference being that under Socialism everybody has the same, under Communism "we the people" represented by the government owns everything. As to Socialism light, you'll have to ask those who think that public libraries define Socialism.

 

The danger is taking those small steps away from individual freedom towards "we the people" collectivism and getting to the point of dependency and unable to come back.

 

What that has to do with "msilaicos" is a mystery


Actually your posting is a mystery. What is Socialism rk?  What countries are actually Socialist?


"The only thing man learns from history is man learns nothing from history"
Report Inappropriate Content
1
Kudos
153
Views
Valued Social Butterfly
1
Kudos
153
Views

Re: Our Ignorance of Socialism Is Dangerous

153 Views
Message 37 of 141

@Soosie wrote:
The point of the topic was to discuss it not to post, "Conservatives think this and Conservatives think that". @rk9152............There is no real discussion here. There are posters who say the same thing over and over, the ones who think their posts are so cute, the ones who say they are so educated, but can't make a good sentence, and those who try to continue to bait. Instead of being called "Politics and Current Events" perhaps some here can come up with a new title.

Since your post offers no discussion on the topic, are you referring to yourself in your posting?


"The only thing man learns from history is man learns nothing from history"
Report Inappropriate Content
1
Kudos
153
Views
Valued Social Butterfly
1
Kudos
150
Views

Re: Our Ignorance of Socialism Is Dangerous

150 Views
Message 38 of 141

@rk9152 wrote:

@Richva wrote:

@rk9152 wrote:

@Richva wrote:

The topic?  I guess our ignorance of Socialism is dangerous since: 
  • Conservatives can not define the term
  • Conservatives believe that more efficient, cost effective, and more effective ways of delivering services as demonstrated by real world experiences must be "Socialist" for reasons they cannot articulate. 
  • Conservatives believe every liberal is a socialist. This is a bit like claiming every liberal is a member of Antifa (of course, we all WANT to be)
  • Conservatives continue to distribute this misinformation. 

Any possibility that we could honestly look at the reality that due to various degrees and definitions PEOPLE do not understand the meaning and potential dangers of Socialism?

 

There is no need to mind read and claim to know what others are thinking in an honest discussion. In that instance a PERSON states what they think.

 

I congratulate jim on trying to get an interesting discussion going. But it has become obvious that some only get defensive when the topic comes up. I don't understand why - the antithesis is Free Market Capitalism and I gladly state and defend my approval of it.


This HAS been an interesting discussion. Do you realize that NOT ONCE was anyone provided  a definition of Socialism?  Well, I did but I took it from the dictionary.  The folks on the right had no idea what they meant by the term and the folks on the left were more interested in whether a set of programs were more or less effective than what was currently in place.  

 

If you can't define what you mean, how can you pretend the ignorance of others is dangerous? 


The meaning of the word was jim's point. And I posted that it is thought of here as everywhere from Marx's theory in toto on one end to public libraries on the other.

 

The point of the topic was to discuss it not to post, "Conservatives think this and Conservatives think that".

 

The danger comes from not being aware of where "Socialism light" can lead.


So then ....... explain what "Socialism light" is and what it can lead to. Since you cannot rationally offer such an explanation without knowing what Socialism is, could you give your definition of it?


"The only thing man learns from history is man learns nothing from history"
Report Inappropriate Content
1
Kudos
150
Views
Valued Social Butterfly
1
Kudos
115
Views

Re: Our Ignorance of Socialism Is Dangerous

115 Views
Message 39 of 141

@rk9152 wrote:

@Richva wrote:

The topic?  I guess our ignorance of Socialism is dangerous since: 
  • Conservatives can not define the term
  • Conservatives believe that more efficient, cost effective, and more effective ways of delivering services as demonstrated by real world experiences must be "Socialist" for reasons they cannot articulate. 
  • Conservatives believe every liberal is a socialist. This is a bit like claiming every liberal is a member of Antifa (of course, we all WANT to be)
  • Conservatives continue to distribute this misinformation. 

Any possibility that we could honestly look at the reality that due to various degrees and definitions PEOPLE do not understand the meaning and potential dangers of Socialism?

 

There is no need to mind read and claim to know what others are thinking in an honest discussion. In that instance a PERSON states what they think.

 

I congratulate jim on trying to get an interesting discussion going. But it has become obvious that some only get defensive when the topic comes up. I don't understand why - the antithesis is Free Market Capitalism and I gladly state and defend my approval of it.


Speaking of interesting, honest, and adult discussion:

 

Since you accuse so many of either being a Socialist, or supporting Socialism, what do you think Socialism is?


"The only thing man learns from history is man learns nothing from history"
Report Inappropriate Content
1
Kudos
115
Views
Valued Social Butterfly
1
Kudos
121
Views

Re: Our Ignorance of Socialism Is Dangerous

121 Views
Message 40 of 141

@rk9152 wrote:


 

 

BTW - we do have posters that praise nations practicing a form of Socialism - you for one, as I recall.

 


So what countries practice true Socialism?


"The only thing man learns from history is man learns nothing from history"
Report Inappropriate Content
1
Kudos
121
Views
cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 
Users
Announcements

Now until February 11, play this classic game online at AARP. Get in the game and play now.


jeopardy for aarp logo

Top Authors