Learn how to use Uber, Lyft and other ride-sharing services!  Register now for a free AARP webinar Nov. 18.

Reply
Valued Social Butterfly
2
Kudos
126
Views

Re: In 'Vietnam War,' Ken Burns Wrestles With The Conflict's Contradictions

126 Views
Message 1 of 3

@Centristsin2010 wrote:

............................................ 

Novick: The soldiers know the lessons. The people who were there, they know what it's like, they know what happened, they know the cost — it's the leaders [who don't]. It's hard to hold on to these lessons.

 

In 'Vietnam War,' Ken Burns Wrestles With The Conflict's Contradictions

 

The series is quite fascinating and enlightening.  Several friends that are Vietnam Vets have said from what they know, the documentary is very accurate and from what they didn't know, said the documentary has pulled several loose ends together.

 

I'd be interested in hearing other Vets views if you are interested in sharing them here.


I am an Air Force veteran of the Korean Police Action.  Because of my AFSC I never really 'got out' of the Air Force upon separation.  National Emergency, declared or not, almost always brought a notice for me to 'report within 24 hours to the nearest AF facility upon further notice'.

 

That notice never came.  My bags stayed packed and one-way transportation stayed arranged for a long time. Viet Nam was another of these.  The United States position made no sense to me then and it still does not. It seemed our Country had lost its way somehow.  It probably was the beginning of my utter disgust with politicians........I was no longer naieve enough to believe what they said was true.  I knew it was not.

Report Inappropriate Content
2
Kudos
126
Views
Treasured Social Butterfly
3
Kudos
151
Views

Re: In 'Vietnam War,' Ken Burns Wrestles With The Conflict's Contradictions

151 Views
Message 2 of 3
I just missed being in it..i was a gung ho kid, but my parents refused to sign when i was 17.. and it was winding down. My wife is 3 years older than me. We often discuss how screwwed up the 60's were as a kid and a tween..i was 13 in 69, she was 19 and the ilitay didnt draft ladies then. For me it kickes off with the assassination of JFK..i was at school and they stopped classes an sent us to the gym, and teachers ere crying and consoling one another..then i see oswald shot on live tv. Newspapers with death tolls everyday, riots, more assasinations, men who fought in the war denouncing it. Crazy times to start forming opinions.

We are watching it online, instead of nightly. What struck me most was in the first episode..the French re occupy and we help..Ho quoting Jefferson at his innaguration. I respect everyone that went and served in that war, but the sad fact is it wasnt called for in the least. A free yet communist Viet Nam wanted to be our ally. We supported depots in the south instead.
So it begins.
Report Inappropriate Content
3
Kudos
151
Views
Treasured Social Butterfly
1
Kudos
165
Views
2
Replies

In 'Vietnam War,' Ken Burns Wrestles With The Conflict's Contradictions

165 Views
Message 3 of 3

In 'Vietnam War,' Ken Burns Wrestles With The Conflict's Contradictions

 

When filmmakers Ken Burns and Lynn Novick began research for a 10-part PBS documentary on the Vietnam War, they thought they knew the material. After all, Burns was of draft age in 1970, though his draft number was too high for him to be called to serve.

 

But as they began interviewing subjects and sorting through archival footage, Burns and Novick soon came to appreciate just how complicated the war was. "We went in, both of us, with this kind of arrogance about it, and immediately had that blown out of the water," Burns says. "We realized we knew nothing."

 

In The Vietnam War, the filmmakers reconcile themselves with the war's inherent contradictions by offering multiple perspectives on the conflict. The series includes interviews with the American, South Vietnamese and North Vietnamese soldiers who fought in it — as well as with Americans who protested against it.

 

Burns and co-director Novick tell Fresh Air that their work on the series deepened their understanding of the war. For his part, Burns likens the documentary to a series of intertwined stories that present "a fundamental fact of not just war, but life, which is: More than one truth can [exist] at the same time."

 

Interview Highlights

 

On the Ho Chi Minh trail, which the North Vietnamese used to move supplies and troops into the South

 

Lynn Novick: The story of the Ho Chi Minh trail, in a way, kind of emblematizes the entire war, because you see the determination and the willingness to sacrifice on an epic scale. There were 20,000 people that were killed maintaining the Ho Chi Minh trail. Many of them were young women who volunteered as something called the youth brigade. There were teenagers that spent years and years under these bombs, working during the night to repair the bomb damage and sleeping during the day when the bombing was happening, because we couldn't bomb at night. They suffered tremendously. ...

 

I think the footage, where you see the fires burning and then women kind of frantically trying to put them out — young women, teenagers — and then they go ahead to try and fill the bomb craters and they're clearly in the middle of a cataclysmic event, is pretty remarkable. The footage of the truck drivers at night going down the trail with these tiny little lights — you can barely see the road in front of them. ... In those moments, we see exactly what the people who were there remember.

 

On why the 1968 Tet Offensive — in which North Vietnamese and Viet Cong forces launched surprise attacks during the Lunar New Year — represented a turning point in Americans' opinion of the war

 

Ken Burns: What [Americans] saw about the Tet Offensive on our television sets, what the reporters brought back and later tried to digest for us, a series of just startling images, [contradicted] the sense that there was light at the end of the tunnel, that we were doing well.

 

Our leaders had been saying, "We're winning this war" ... and everything that the Tet Offensive revealed in pictures suggested the exact opposite. Though it was, in fact, a catastrophic defeat for the North and for the Viet Cong; they suffered losses — dead, not just casualties, in the tens of thousands. But the thing was it was a huge public relations victory for them, because we had not been quite frank and honest and transparent with the American people. We hadn't been so for years.

 

On the famous photo and television footage of a Viet Cong operative being executed in the street

 

Novick: This is a devastating image taken by Eddie Adams of The Associated Press. The head of the South Vietnamese National Police, Gen. [Nguyen Ngoc] Loan, is basically with a scrum of other officers and they have a Viet Cong operative who they've captured, and essentially Gen. Loan assassinates him on the streets of Saigon in broad daylight with this photographer watching and NBC cameras rolling. ...

 

There were assassinations and retaliations and atrocities in the streets of Saigon during the Tet Offensive on both sides. This is the one that was captured on film with this incredible photograph, where it's the moment of impact of the bullet in this man's head and he's about to die. And that photograph was on front pages of newspapers around the world, and was shocking and devastating and kind of makes everybody who saw it complicit in this act, in a way. You're part of it; it's happening and you're there. And that had deep impact on the American public and the world about what's happening in this war. ...

 

NBC does not ordinarily license that footage for obvious reasons, and they would only let us license it if we would show what was actually shown on television. So our producer Sarah Botstein and her team spent a lot of time working back and forth with NBC to determine, exactly to the frame, what was shown, and not a frame longer or shorter. And that is what we put in the film. We frame it on a television set because we wanted our audience to see what the American public saw. It was only shown once on television.

 

On finding new footage of the 1970 shooting at Kent State University, in which four students were killed when the Ohio National Guard opened fire during a Vietnam War protest

 

Novick: [The] shooting lasted 13 seconds — that's a long time. A lot of bullets were fired. Just seeing the images — one of the things that was so powerful was that there's some footage that we didn't quite know where it came from, and our producer Mike Welt tracked it down and it was a student at Kent State who had a camera that day. ... He had been filming the demonstrations, and he kept rolling his camera as people were getting shot, and there was blood on the street, and people were screaming and crying and he just followed it around. And after that moment, [he] was so disturbed by what he had seen and recorded that he never was the same.

 

The footage ended up in his garage or in his family's garage and Mike Welt tracked them down after a year and they were willing to let us have access to these cans of film that no one had looked at.

 

On the lessons of war

 

Burns: I think history has made me an optimist, despite the fact that it shows you that human nature doesn't change — that the same venality is present, the same abstraction of war is present, the same greed is present, but so is also the same generosity and the same love.

 

War is human nature on steroids ... and we assume it [is] just all negative, but in fact the free electrons that war gives off (in all the instances that I've tried to tackle it) reveal as much about the positive sides of human nature. ...

 

We could reasonably assume to be huddled in the fetal position, but we don't. We raise families and we plant gardens and we write symphonies and we try to make films and talk about history. Maybe there's something that comes from that that sticks.

 

Novick: The soldiers know the lessons. The people who were there, they know what it's like, they know what happened, they know the cost — it's the leaders [who don't]. It's hard to hold on to these lessons.

 

In 'Vietnam War,' Ken Burns Wrestles With The Conflict's Contradictions

 

The series is quite fascinating and enlightening.  Several friends that are Vietnam Vets have said from what they know, the documentary is very accurate and from what they didn't know, said the documentary has pulled several loose ends together.

 

I'd be interested in hearing other Vets views if you are interested in sharing them here.


"FAKE 45 #illegitimate" read a sign at the Woman's March in Washington DC, January 21, 2017.
Report Inappropriate Content
1
Kudos
165
Views
2
Replies
cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 
Users
Announcements

Open Enrollment: Oct 15-Dec 7, 2019 Find resources to help you decide on the best healthcare insurance plans for you during Open Enrollment season

Top Authors