Humana Pharmacy Plan Problem

I have been on the Humana pharmacy plan for a number of years. In October I asked to be put on the Humana Walmart Value plan which costs $13.20 per month.  Today my checking account was charged $58 for the Premier plan.


I called  customer service and it was confirmed that it was Humana's fault. However, I was told that as it was after December 7, the plan could not be changed.


I was further told that I could cancel the plan but i would have to pay a Medicare penalty for not having a pharmacy plan.


Do I have any other options?



0 Kudos
Honored Social Butterfly


Guess you should have doubled checked your choice on your "" site before the 1st premium came due.  How do you and customer service know that it was Humana's fault for the mixup?


Here is how it should have been done -

AARP: Do I have to reenroll in my Medicare Part D prescription drug plan every year? 


. . . . As a first step, pay attention to a letter you’ll receive from your plan in September. This is the Annual Notice of Change that Medicare requires plans to send to all of their enrollees.


. . . .Reviewing the Annual Notice of Change provides you with a basis to compare your current plan with others offered in your area for the following year. You can make this comparison during the annual open enrollment period (Oct. 15 to Dec. 7). You can use the online plan-finder program on Medicare’s website ( to identify the plan that covers your drugs at the least out-of-pocket cost, or call Medicare at 800-633-4227 and ask a customer service representative to do the search for you. 


After making this comparison, if you want to switch to another Part D plan, you can enroll online on Medicare’s plan-finder website, or call Medicare, or call the plan. You do not have to inform your current plan. Signing up with a new plan automatically cancels your coverage from the old one. Your new coverage will begin Jan. 1.  


After making your choice, you can verify that the plan was correctly entered by checking your page.


somarco is right - you have to call and talk to Medicare to see what they MIGHT do for you.  Maybe . . . . if you have some proof that Humana did it wrong.


You do have some rights; just like everybody -  might take some work since you will be working with government but there is a lot of difference between those premiums; especially, I am assuming, that you take few meds and thus don't need the Premier plan. - Your rights in Medicare drug plans 


Yes, if you cancel a plan and don't get another - the penalty will apply

Medicare Part D Late Enrollment Penalty 


Bronze Conversationalist

Go back 6 or 8 years ago and the Humana/WM PDP was around $15 in Georgia. Last year it was $30 and now $60 for 2020.


The "new" Humana/WM plan here is $13.


Read your ANOC.


Shop and compare during AEP.


Take ownership for your oversight.

Bark less. Wag more.
0 Kudos
Bronze Conversationalist

It's Humana's fault if they failed to mail you the ANOC in September, 2019.


Otherwise, I suspect you did not open your mail prior to or during AEP.


You can complain to Medicare (800-MEDICARE). They might grant you a special SEP to transition to a new plan. Otherwise you are stuck.


The Humana Walmart plan (like most carriers) has changed considerably over the last 5 years or so. Higher premiums, higher copay's just to name a few. With few exceptions, the Humana/Walmart plan has not been a good choice for many for at least 4 years.


Folks are always encouraged to READ the ANOC as well as SHOP your drug plan every year, but few do.


If Medicare does not provide you some relief make a note in your calendar to shop drug plans when October rolls around.


Good luck!

Bark less. Wag more.
Showing results for 
Show  only  | Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

To our Online Community Members,

We wanted to let you know that our Community Guidelines and Terms of Service have been updated. The changes are intended to foster more civil discussions in AARP’s online communities. The issues discussed in these communities – including healthcare, retirement and politics – are serious and stir up strong emotions. We should have spirited debates about all of them, but those debates should always be respectful, on topic and fact based. We will be applying these standards in our online communities as we work together, with all of you, to address the challenges that face older Americans. Thank you.

AARP Membership Flash Sale

AARP Games

Throw it back and play Atari's Missile Command. Grab your arsenal to neutralize your enemy and protect your cities from a missile attack. You got this!

AARP Games Atari Missile Command

Your Daily Puzzle

Enjoy our interactive brain-teasers and treat yourself to some mental gymnastics. Try one today.

Your Daily Puzzle