topic Re: WARNING - Don't purchase Papa John Gift Card in Redemption

WARNING - Don't purchase Papa John Gift Card

RiverBoatAndrew — Sun, 14 Dec 2025 13:06:18 GMT

I just purchased a Papa John's $5 gift card (Sunday morning 12/14) and AARP sent me an ULTA BEAUTY GIFT CARD instead of the Papa John Card. So how do I return it for what I ordered? I DON'T WANT AN ULTA BEAUTY GIFT CARD!

Re: WARNING - Don't purchase Papa John Gift Card

sh30592221 — Sun, 14 Dec 2025 13:09:55 GMT

I also tried to purchase a Papa John gift card and they also sent me an U BEAUTY gift card instead! This site is plagued with problems and issues! 😞

Re: WARNING - Don't purchase Papa John Gift Card

SereneSeagull — Sun, 14 Dec 2025 15:11:43 GMT

Yep, read about that yesterday. Also those who used points for Panera card got a Marshall’s card instead.

Some have come here saying they got their points back for that mix up. But I don’t think they were given the card they were supposed to get at all. Doesn’t sound like any explanation on it or the reimbursement either was given to them, just points appears back in their accounts. They don’t even know if the wrong card can be used or got deactivated.

Re: WARNING - Don't purchase Papa John Gift Card

Barbisme — Sun, 14 Dec 2025 17:06:39 GMT

Big bummer! Am wondering whether a real person is goofing them up or if it’s an AI or some other automated code-writing program gone rogue?

Re: WARNING - Don't purchase Papa John Gift Card

SereneSeagull — Sun, 14 Dec 2025 17:09:32 GMT

Sounds like someone coded wrong to me.

Re: WARNING - Don't purchase Papa John Gift Card

RiverBoatAndrew — Mon, 15 Dec 2025 11:54:05 GMT

And for a $5 gift card it isn't worth the time to call AARP customer service and deal with them. Doesn't give me much confidence for any future purchases on this site! 🫤

Re: WARNING - Don't purchase Papa John Gift Card

KristBelt — Tue, 07 Apr 2026 23:24:46 GMT

Wish I had a Papa John's card to trade for your Ulta card...

(Unless that wold be against the "terms & conditions", or rules, of course.)

Re: WARNING - Don't purchase Papa John Gift Card

RiverBoatAndrew — Wed, 01 Apr 2026 11:54:46 GMT

And now today, April 1, 2026, I purchased 2 gift cards and so far have received NOTHING 🤔🫤🤨☹️😡